1. RNP
  2. Motor Learning
  3. Key authors in motor learning
  4. Schmidt & Lee 2019

Motor LearningSeries 11/13

SeriesKey authors in motor learning11 of 13

Schmidt & Lee 2019

Schmidt & Lee 2019 establishes the distinction between performance and learning that underpins how RNP qualifies calibration versus compensation.

LabO RNP·3 min read·reviewed on

In brief. In RNP, Schmidt & Lee 2019 refers to the scientific lineage tied to NIT that formalizes the distinction between performance (the immediate observed effect) and learning (a persistent, transferable and lasting effect). The sixth edition of Motor Control and Learning: A Behavioral Emphasis (Richard Schmidt, Timothy Lee, 2019) shapes how NIT is put into practice today and underpins the distinction between calibration and compensation that is specific to RNP.

Why is Schmidt & Lee 2019 central for the human movement professional?

Schmidt & Lee 2019 is one of the founding scientific lineages of NIT and of the calibration vs compensation distinction in RNP. Its practical value comes from the depth of its distinction between performance and learning, which grounds the multi-temporal qualification of lasting calibration. RNP treats Schmidt & Lee 2019 as a core lineage of NIT and of the T-S-R method (Test–Stimulation–Retest cycle).

The lineage brings several major contributions to RNP. The distinction between performance and learning (immediate effect versus a persistent, transferable and lasting effect). A formal account of the conditions for lasting learning (contextual variation, spacing, delayed feedback). Consistency with the RNP distinction between calibration and compensation. A link to multi-temporal qualification (day 7 and day 21 at minimum). See also: Calibration vs compensation: the same result never costs the same price.

RNP integrates Schmidt & Lee at several points. See also: Bernstein 1967, Davids, Button & Bennett: Dynamics of Skill Acquisition (2008), Calibration vs compensation: the same result never costs the same price.

Schmidt & Lee 2019 is the scientific lineage that establishes the distinction between performance and learning at the heart of RNP calibration.

How the lineage applies in practice

The lineage applies in qualifying performance and learning separately, in calibrating through conditions that favor lasting learning, and in multi-temporal retesting.

Qualifying performance and learning separately. You assess the immediate delta (a performance indicator) separately from multi-temporal durability (a learning indicator) (see Calibration vs compensation: the same result never costs the same price). You refuse to conclude that learning has occurred on the basis of the immediate delta alone.

Calibrating through conditions that favor lasting learning. You structure stimulations with contextual variation, temporal spacing and appropriate feedback to promote lasting learning. You build this work into the RNP T-S-R cycle.

Multi-temporal retesting. You retest immediately (performance), at day 7 (short-term retention) and at day 21 (lasting learning, at minimum). You explicitly name the level of qualification reached.

The RNP training space, free for life

Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.

Welcome! Introduce yourself

SecureNo cardNo password

By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.

What you often hear

The first misconception comes from relying solely on the immediate reading. You hear: “If the immediate delta is positive, we’ve calibrated.” The immediate delta indicates performance, not lasting learning.

The second misconception comes from quick promises. You hear: “With these favorable conditions, we’ll establish learning in a few sessions.” Lasting retention requires minimum time windows before it can be qualified.

The third misconception comes from setting it in radical opposition to ecological dynamics. You hear: “Schmidt & Lee is the opposite of Davids, Button & Bennett; it’s one or the other.” The paradigmatic tension combines the approaches sequentially.

Schmidt & Lee 2019 is the core lineage that establishes the distinction between performance and learning at the heart of RNP calibration.

Further reading

Core concept: Calibration vs compensation: the same result never costs the same price

T-S-R method: Calibration vs compensation: the same result never costs the same price

Scientific lineages: Bernstein 1967 · Gibson 1979 · Newell's Constraints Model (1986) · Davids, Button & Bennett: Dynamics of Skill Acquisition (2008)

Paradigmatic tension: Active inference (Friston, 2010) · Clark: Predictive Processing and Surfing Uncertainty (2013-2016)

NIT functional levels: Motor automatization

Going further

Schmidt & Lee 2019 belongs to the contemporary tradition of motor learning and has shaped practical reference points for several decades.

Richard Schmidt and Timothy Lee have published several editions of Motor Control and Learning: A Behavioral Emphasis (Human Kinetics) since 1982. The sixth edition (2019) consolidates the core distinctions and formalizations.

The distinction between performance and learning structures a large part of the contemporary motor learning literature. RNP adopts this distinction as the foundation for qualifying calibration versus compensation.

Now, in practice

Do you work in rehabilitation? Read Calibration vs compensation: the same result never costs the same price to connect Schmidt & Lee with a rigorous assessment of durability in your work with adult clients.

Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements health care; it does not replace it. In RNP, Schmidt & Lee 2019 refers to a scientific lineage tied to NIT.

€0Your free RNP PathsStart