1. RNP
  2. Motor Learning
  3. Predict, err, recalibrate: how the system learns
  4. Clark: Predictive Processing and Surfing Uncertainty (2013-2016)

Motor LearningSeries 7/9

SeriesPredict, err, recalibrate: how the system learns7 of 9

Clark: Predictive Processing and Surfing Uncertainty (2013-2016)

Andy Clark's philosophical synthesis makes contemporary predictive coding and active inference accessible.

LabO RNP·3 min read·reviewed on

In short. Andy Clark is the philosopher of cognitive science (University of Edinburgh, then University of Sussex) who gave Friston's framework a philosophical, usable form. He did this in Whatever Next? Predictive Brains, Situated Agents, and the Future of Cognitive Science (Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 2013) and then in Surfing Uncertainty: Prediction, Action, and the Embodied Mind (Oxford University Press, 2016). His synthesis made Friston's framework accessible to clinical practitioners without advanced mathematical training. This scientific lineage is linked to Friston and integrated into NIT.

Why is Andy Clark central for the human movement professional?

Andy Clark is one of the most effective at turning Friston's framework into usable philosophy for the non-academic human movement professional. RNP treats Clark as one of the accessible sources of the predictive lineage behind NIT. It connects his work with Friston (the mathematical side) and with ecological dynamics (Gibson-Bernstein).

Clark's contribution brings together several central and accessible ideas. First, the mind is an embodied predictive engine that surfs uncertainty by continuously minimizing prediction error. Second, action is active inference: it changes the world so that incoming data match internal predictions. Third, the mind is embodied and does not separate cognition from action. See also: Active inference (Friston).

RNP integrates Clark at several points of connection. See also: Efference copy (von Holst-Mittelstaedt 1950).

Andy Clark is not a simplified popularization. His work is the philosophical synthesis that makes contemporary predictive coding and active inference accessible to the non-academic human movement professional.

How Clark's contribution applies in practice

His contribution applies in three areas: understanding the predictive engine, connecting it to active inference, and calibrating teaching around prediction.

Understanding the predictive engine. You bring the Clark-Friston view of the nervous system as an embodied predictive engine into your understanding of pre-reflexive motor decisions (see Active inference (Friston)).

Connecting to active inference. You treat prediction and action together in an integrated clinical reading, not as separate steps (see Active inference (Friston)).

Calibrating teaching. You calibrate your teaching across the four functional levels by sequencing approaches: Clark-Friston approaches at the early levels, ecological dynamics at the advanced levels.

The RNP training space, free for life

Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.

Welcome! Introduce yourself

SecureNo cardNo password

By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.

What you hear people say

The first objection comes from a disembodied cognitivist reading. His framework is explicitly embodied.

The second comes from a single-paradigm reading.

The third comes from marketing simplification.

Clark's contribution is not disembodied cognitivism, not a single-paradigm argument, and not a marketing simplification.

Further reading

Core concept and lineage: Active inference (Friston) · Efference copy (von Holst-Mittelstaedt 1950) · Prediction–reafference mismatch: why your system only learns when its forecast is wrong · Motor recalibration (learning mechanism)

Paradigmatic tension: Variability versus repetition

Ecological dynamics: Ecological dynamics · Affordance: what your athlete sees before moving (and that you never correct) · Bernstein: Coordination and the degrees of freedom problem (1967) · Davids, Button & Bennett: Dynamics of Skill Acquisition (2008) · Rob Gray: How We Learn to Move and contemporary perception-action

Affective neuroscience: Somatic markers (Damasio) · Craig: interoception and the insula (2002)

NIT and levels: Motor automatization

Tools: Internal versus External Focus of Attention (Wulf) · Augmented feedback (KR and KP) · Optimal learning zone (70-80%)

Scientific lineage: Scientific lineage of Neuro-Postural Reprogramming (meta-map)

Going further

Andy Clark published his landmark article Whatever Next? Predictive Brains, Situated Agents, and the Future of Cognitive Science in Behavioral and Brain Sciences in 2013 (36, 181-204). The article brought Friston's framework to a wide audience across the cognitive sciences.

His major book, Surfing Uncertainty: Prediction, Action, and the Embodied Mind (Oxford University Press, 2016), gathered this philosophical treatment of Friston's framework for a broad readership. It has become a reference in embodied cognitive science.

His work extends the tradition of embodied cognitive science (extended mind, situated cognition) and connects it to Friston's predictive framework. This connection is one of the most influential in contemporary cognitive science.

RNP places Clark in the predictive lineage of NIT, alongside Friston (the mathematical framework) and ecological dynamics (Gibson-Bernstein-Davids-Gray).

Now, in practice

Do you coach or prepare athletes? Read Active inference (Friston) to apply the Clark-Friston view of predictive motor decisions to your athletes.

Do you support learning and emotions? Read Craig: interoception and the insula (2002) to link Clark to the neuro-affective reading of children.

Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements health care; it does not replace it. Clark's work is a contemporary philosophical legacy linked to NIT within non-medical motor learning.

€0Your free RNP PathsStart