- RNP
- Motor Learning
- Predict, err, recalibrate: how the system learns
- Efference copy (von Holst & Mittelstaedt, 1950)
SeriesPredict, err, recalibrate: how the system learns2 of 9
Efference copy (von Holst & Mittelstaedt, 1950)
Efference copy, formalized in 1950, is the core neuro-functional mechanism behind sensory prediction.
In short. In RNP, efference copy refers to the neuro-functional mechanism formalized by Erich von Holst and Horst Mittelstaedt (1950, Das Reafferenzprinzip). When the nervous system sends a motor command to the muscles, it also sends a copy of that command to the integrative sensory structures. Those structures can then predict the expected sensory consequences of a movement before it happens. It is the founding mechanism of the predictive lineage integrated into NIT.
Why is efference copy central for the human movement professional?
Efference copy is the founding neurophysiological concept that explains how the nervous system can predict the sensory consequences of a movement before it happens. RNP treats this mechanism as one of the foundations of the predictive lineage. That lineage sits alongside ecological dynamics within the paradigmatic tension specific to NIT.
The mechanism rests on several principles. First, every voluntary motor command sent to the muscles is duplicated as an efference copy and sent to the integrative sensory structures. Second, this efference copy allows those sensory structures to anticipate the expected sensory reafference. Third, the system compares the prediction (the projected efference copy) with the reafference actually received. That comparison produces the prediction error signal (mismatch) that drives motor learning. See also: Prediction–reafference mismatch: why your system only learns when its forecast is wrong.
See also: Active inference (Friston).
Efference copy is the founding mechanism of the predictive lineage integrated into NIT. It explains how the nervous system can predict the sensory consequences of a movement.
How efference copy applies in practice
Efference copy applies in three areas: understanding pre-reflexive motor decision, reading prediction dysfunctions, and calibrating prediction-related motor teaching.
Understanding pre-reflexive motor decision. The RNP practitioner reads the pre-reflexive motor decision in the window of two hundred to three hundred milliseconds before observable execution, and that decision includes the efference copy mechanism (see Motor decision: not a command, the pre-reflexive act you have 280 milliseconds to read). You read the predictive quality of the motor decision.
Reading prediction dysfunctions. You read the clinical signs of impaired prediction: hesitant movement, frequent corrective adjustments, slow initiation, and poor anticipation. These signs point toward a reading that articulates functional neurology with NIT.
Calibrating articulated teaching. At the initial functional levels, you set up teaching that engages and refines prediction through internal focus and augmented feedback. At advanced levels, you move to ecological teaching that preserves direct perception-action coupling.
The RNP training space, free for life
Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.
What you hear people say
The first confusion comes from a disembodied cognitivist reading. You hear that "efference copy is an abstract cognitive concept." In fact, it is an embodied neuro-anatomical mechanism with experimental documentation.
The second confusion concerns consciousness. You hear that "efference copy is a conscious prediction." It is largely subconscious and precedes any awareness of the prediction.
The third confusion comes from a single-paradigm reading. You hear that "efference copy proves ecological dynamics wrong." RNP rejects any single-paradigm reading and favors sequential articulation instead.
Efference copy is an embodied neuro-functional mechanism. It founds the predictive lineage, which NIT articulates sequentially with ecological dynamics.
Further reading
Core concept and mechanism: Prediction–reafference mismatch: why your system only learns when its forecast is wrong · Motor recalibration (learning mechanism)
Predictive lineage: Active inference (Friston) · Clark: Predictive Processing and Surfing Uncertainty (2013–2016)
Paradigmatic tension: Variability versus repetition
Ecological dynamics: Ecological dynamics · Affordance · Perception-action coupling · Direct Perception (Gibson) · Bernstein: Coordination and the degrees of freedom problem (1967)
Motor decision: Motor decision: not a command, the pre-reflexive act you have 280 milliseconds to read · Sensorimotor loop · Reflex arc versus sensorimotor loop
NIT and levels: Motor automatization
Tools: Internal versus External Focus of Attention (Wulf) · Augmented feedback (KR and KP) · Optimal learning zone (70–80%)
Going further
Erich von Holst and Horst Mittelstaedt formalized efference copy in their founding paper Das Reafferenzprinzip (Wechselwirkungen zwischen Zentralnervensystem und Peripherie). It was published in 1950 in Naturwissenschaften (37, 464–476).
The paper formalized the idea that the nervous system sends out a motor command and, at the same time, an efference copy to the integrative sensory structures. This formalization laid the groundwork for the entire contemporary lineage of predictive motor coding and sensory prediction in neuroscience.
The contemporary predictive coding tradition (Karl Friston 2010, Andy Clark 2013) broadened the efference copy mechanism into a general theoretical framework of prediction error minimization. See also: Active inference (Friston).
Contemporary motor control neuroscience has confirmed the efference copy mechanism experimentally in several brain structures, including the cerebellum, the basal ganglia and the motor cortex.
Now, in practice
Do you coach or train athletes? Read Prediction–reafference mismatch: why your system only learns when its forecast is wrong to understand the predictive engine behind your athletes' learning.
Do you work in rehabilitation? Read the article on reading prediction dysfunctions to learn how to spot them in clients recovering motor function.
Do you support learning and emotional development? Read Motor decision: not a command, the pre-reflexive act you have 280 milliseconds to read to connect efference copy with a child's neuromotor development.
Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements medical care; it does not replace it. Efference copy refers to a neurophysiological mechanism related to NIT within the field of non-medical motor learning.