1. RNP
  2. Motor Learning
  3. Nonlinear pedagogy (Chow, Davids et al. 2007)

Motor LearningSeries 1/4

SeriesEcological pedagogies: constraints, variation, representative situations1 of 4

Nonlinear pedagogy (Chow, Davids et al. 2007)

The nonlinear pedagogy grounded in dynamical systems theory that calibrates self-organization under constraints.

LabO RNP·4 min read·reviewed on

In brief. Nonlinear pedagogy is the ecological teaching framework formalized by Jia Yi Chow, Keith Davids, Chris Button, Ian Renshaw, Stephen Shuttleworth, Duarte Araujo and Karl Newell (Nonlinear Pedagogy in Skill Acquisition: An Introduction, 2007). It links the constraint-led approach to a dynamical systems perspective. It rejects linear, prescriptive teaching in favor of calibrating self-organization under constraints. It is an operational teaching framework built into NIT as one of its core contemporary sources.

Why is nonlinear pedagogy central for the human movement professional?

Nonlinear pedagogy is one of the most fully developed contemporary applications of the ecological framework that runs from Gibson through Bernstein to Newell. It links the constraint-led approach to a dynamical systems perspective and gives the human movement professional a coherent teaching framework. That framework structures learning progression without falling back on traditional linear prescription.

Its contribution rests on several operational principles. First, motor learning is not a linear, sequential process of acquiring techniques. It is a nonlinear process of self-organization under constraints, with phases of stability, critical transitions and attractor states. Second, teaching must calibrate constraints to steer self-organization toward the adaptive coordination patterns you are after. Third, structured functional variability and informational representativeness are the operational teaching levers. See also: Constraint-led approach (CLA).

See also: Representative learning design (Pinder & Davids 2011), Functional variability (ecological dynamics).

Nonlinear pedagogy is not just one teaching school among others. It is one of the core contemporary applications of the ecological dynamics framework built into NIT, linking the constraint-led approach to a dynamical systems perspective.

How nonlinear pedagogy applies in practice

It applies in three ways: reading the nonlinear phases of learning, calibrating constraints to the current phase, and tolerating critical transitions.

Reading the nonlinear phases. You read motor learning as a nonlinear process with distinct phases. First comes a stability phase, in which an existing coordination pattern holds. Then comes a critical transition phase, in which that existing pattern destabilizes. Finally, an emergence phase brings a new, more adaptive coordination pattern. This reading means you stop expecting steady, linear progress.

Calibrating constraints to the phase. You calibrate teaching constraints to the nonlinear phase under way. In the stability phase, you apply minimal constraints to consolidate the coordination pattern. In the critical transition phase, you increase constraints to encourage the new pattern to emerge. In the emergence phase, you apply stabilizing constraints to consolidate the new pattern.

Tolerating critical transitions. You accept that critical transitions temporarily degrade performance. This tolerance is a defining feature of nonlinear pedagogy. It sets the RNP practitioner apart from the strength and conditioning coach who would stop the learning process at the first dip.

The RNP training space, free for life

Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.

Welcome! Introduce yourself

SecureNo cardNo password

By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.

What you'll hear

First misconception: free improvisation. You'll hear "nonlinear pedagogy just means letting them get on with it." In fact, nonlinear pedagogy deliberately calibrates constraints to steer self-organization. It is not free improvisation. See also: Constraint-led approach (CLA).

Second misconception: rejecting all progression. You'll hear "nonlinear pedagogy rejects any kind of progression." Nonlinear pedagogy does recognize progression. It simply treats it as a nonlinear process with distinct phases rather than as continuous, linear progress.

Third misconception: the marketing promise. You'll hear "nonlinear pedagogy guarantees adaptive learning." Nonlinear pedagogy is a solid teaching framework, but it guarantees nothing automatically.

Nonlinear pedagogy is a contemporary application of the ecological dynamics framework, built into NIT.

Further reading

Core concept: Attractor: why your correction holds for two repetitions then fades · Attractor landscape

Ecological dynamics: Ecological dynamics · Constraint-led approach (CLA) · Representative learning design (Pinder & Davids 2011) · Differential learning (Schöllhorn) · Functional variability (ecological dynamics)

Founding lineage: Newell's Constraints Model (1986) · Bernstein: Coordination and the degrees of freedom problem (1967) · Affordance: what your athlete sees before moving (and you never correct) · Davids, Button & Bennett: Dynamics of Skill Acquisition (2008) · Rob Gray: How We Learn to Move and contemporary perception-action

Going further

Jia Yi Chow (National Institute of Education, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore), Keith Davids, Chris Button, Ian Renshaw, Stephen Shuttleworth, Duarte Araujo and Karl Newell published the founding text, Nonlinear Pedagogy in Skill Acquisition: An Introduction, in 2007 (Routledge).

The book brings together several traditions. The first is Newell's tradition (the 1986 constraints model). The second is Davids' tradition (Dynamics of Skill Acquisition, 2008). The third is the dynamical systems tradition (Esther Thelen, Mark Latash, Anatol Feldman). Together, they produce a coherent teaching framework that structures nonlinear learning progression.

Later work building on Chow and Davids (Tan, Chow and Davids 2012, 2017; Chow, Davids, Renshaw, Hammond and Komar 2020) extended this approach across a range of sport and teaching contexts.

French-language applications are still taking shape. RNP builds this source into NIT within the RNP Path.

Now, in practice

Do you coach or condition athletes? Read Nonlinear learning phases to bring nonlinear pedagogy into your strength and conditioning sessions.

Do you work in rehabilitation? Read Critical transitions in learning to learn how to tolerate critical transitions during return-to-activity programs.

Do you support learning and emotional development? Read Dynamical systems and motor learning to bring the nonlinear perspective into children's motor development.

Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements medical care; it does not replace it. Nonlinear pedagogy refers to a teaching application linked to NIT within the field of non-medical ecological motor learning.

€0Your free RNP PathsStart