1. RNP
  2. Motor Learning
  3. Key authors in motor learning
  4. Rob Gray: How We Learn to Move and contemporary perception-action

Motor LearningSeries 12/13

SeriesKey authors in motor learning12 of 13

Rob Gray: How We Learn to Move and contemporary perception-action

This is not classical cognitive motor learning. It is the contemporary ecological synthesis of How We Learn to Move, written for the human movement professional.

LabO RNP·6 min read·reviewed on

In brief. Rob Gray is a professor of cognitive psychology and a sport science researcher at Arizona State University. He has brought the practical teaching implications of ecological motor learning to an informed general audience. His book How We Learn to Move: A Revolution in the Way We Coach and Practice Sports Skills (2020) combines Gibson, Bernstein, Newell, Davids and Schöllhorn into a practical synthesis that human movement professionals can use directly. He belongs to the contemporary scientific lineage connected to NIT.

Why is Rob Gray central for the human movement professional?

Rob Gray is one of the most effective contemporary communicators of ecological motor learning for human movement professionals outside academia. RNP treats his book How We Learn to Move (2020) as one of the accessible foundational sources of NIT. It is also one of the main teaching resources for RNP-trained professionals who want to go deeper into the ecological lineage after their initial LabO training.

Gray's contribution brings together several ideas that are central to contemporary coaching. First, motor learning is not the cognitive storage of internal representations of correct movements. It is the education of perceptual sensitivity to the informational invariants that matter for the target task. Fifty years of ecological research support this Gibsonian premise. Second, an external focus on the goal of the task consistently outperforms an internal focus on the details of the movement, especially at advanced functional levels. This idea comes from Wulf and is confirmed by recent meta-analyses, which Gray presents in accessible terms. Third, functional variability structured through constraints is a better teaching tool than standardized repetition for developing adaptive capacity and robustness under constraint.

See also: Internal versus External Focus of Attention (Wulf), Functional variability (ecological dynamics).

Rob Gray is not a peripheral academic reference. He is one of the leading contemporary communicators of ecological motor learning for the human movement professional, and one of the accessible reference sources in strength and conditioning connected to NIT.

How Gray's work applies in practice

Gray's work applies in three areas: calibrating external focus, building structured functional variability, and reading the informational invariants of the target task.

Calibrating external focus. You adjust your client's or athlete's attentional focus to the functional level they have reached (see Internal versus External Focus of Attention (Wulf)). At the adaptive capacity and robustness under constraint levels (NIT levels 3 and 4), an external focus on the goal of the task consistently comes first. Wulf's research shows that keeping an internal focus at these levels works against transfer, and Gray presents this finding clearly.

Building structured functional variability. You vary training situations according to the ecological approach Gray describes (see Functional variability (ecological dynamics), Differential learning (Schöllhorn)). This means varying contextual constraints such as surface, lighting, partner, load and speed. It also means varying linked sub-tasks: change of direction with the ball, without the ball, or under simulated defensive pressure. Finally, it means varying the emotional and cognitive context: training while fatigued, under the cognitive load of a dual task, or in a simulated competitive setting. See also: Representative learning design (Pinder Davids 2011).

Reading the informational invariants of the target task. You identify the informational invariants available in the target task, as described by Gibson and Gray, and use them to guide your coaching (see Informational invariants). In sprinting, you look at the invariants in the optic flow of the moving horizon. For a change of direction in team sports, you look at the visual invariants of the opponent's position and of the playing surface. For hitting the ball in tennis, you look at the timing invariants of the incoming trajectory. What you read in these invariants shapes how you design the practice situations. See also: Specifying versus non-specifying information.

The RNP training space, free for life

Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.

Welcome! Introduce yourself

SecureNo cardNo password

By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.

What people often say

The first misunderstanding comes from a shallow, popularized reading. You hear "Rob Gray says you just need to vary the drills." Gray's synthesis is not a quick recipe. It condenses fifty years of ecological research into a structured working framework, and applying it well requires a solid grasp of the principles.

The second misunderstanding comes from a disembodied cognitivist opposition. You hear "Gray rejects any internal representation." Gray faithfully presents the Gibsonian ecological framework, which holds that perception is direct and needs no internal representation. RNP, however, connects this framework to Friston's predictive coding, which holds the opposite view.

The third misunderstanding comes from overreach driven by coaching marketing. You hear "Gray's ecological approach guarantees the development of adaptive capacity." Contemporary ecological coaching is a solid working framework. It does not automatically build adaptive capacity in every athlete, regardless of their profile and of the test-stimulation-retest cycle.

Gray's work is an accessible and rigorous contemporary synthesis of ecological motor learning, connected to NIT.

Further reading

Gray's core concepts: Internal versus External Focus of Attention (Wulf) · Functional variability (ecological dynamics) · Specifying versus non-specifying information

Ecological lineage: Affordance: what your athlete sees before moving (and that you never correct) · Bernstein: Coordination and the degrees of freedom problem (1967) · Newell's Constraints Model (1986) · Davids, Button & Bennett: Dynamics of Skill Acquisition (2008) · Frans Bosch: Anatomy in Motion and ecological strength & conditioning · Differential learning (Schöllhorn)

Ecological dynamics: Ecological dynamics · Affordance: what your athlete sees before moving (and that you never correct) · Perception-action coupling: why your athletes fail when the information moves · Informational invariants · Direct Perception (Gibson) · Perceptual calibration: why correcting the movement never changes anything

Putting it into practice: Constraint-led approach (CLA) · Nonlinear pedagogy (Chow Davids 2007) · Representative learning design (Pinder Davids 2011) · Differential learning (Schöllhorn) · Augmented feedback (KR and KP) · Guidance hypothesis: why your help works today and betrays you tomorrow

NIT and functional levels: Motor automatization · Motor far transfer (qualifying learning)

Paradigmatic tension: Active inference (Friston) · Clark: Predictive Processing and Surfing Uncertainty (2013-2016)

Going further

Rob Gray (Arizona State University, Tempe, USA) is a professor of cognitive psychology and a sport science researcher. He specializes in perception-action in interceptive sports (baseball, cricket, tennis) and in contemporary ecological coaching. His scientific publications span twenty years of experimental research on baseball batting, the perception of ball motion, and the practical application of Gibson's ecological framework to coaching.

His major book, How We Learn to Move: A Revolution in the Way We Coach and Practice Sports Skills (2020, Rob Gray Press, translated into several languages), summarizes the current state of ecological motor learning for human movement professionals outside academia. The book is built around four teaching principles: variability, external focus, the constraint-led approach and representative learning design. Gray illustrates each one with accessible practical examples.

His podcast, The Perception & Action Podcast (launched in 2014, with several hundred episodes), has helped spread ecological motor learning among English-speaking strength and conditioning coaches, sports physical therapists and sport coaches. Through this practical outreach, ecological coaching moved beyond a small academic circle and became widespread professional practice in several countries.

Gray's work brings together several distinct traditions that RNP incorporates indirectly into NIT. The first is the founding ecological tradition (Gibson 1979, Bernstein 1967). The second is contemporary perception-action research in interceptive sports (Williams, Davids, Gray, 1990s-2020). The third is ecological motor learning (Davids, Button & Bennett 2008; Pinder 2011). The fourth is nonlinear pedagogy (Chow, Davids, Button, Renshaw, Shuttleworth, Araujo, Newell 2007, Nonlinear Pedagogy in Skill Acquisition). See also: Nonlinear pedagogy (Chow Davids 2007).

Related contemporary literature extends the framework that Gray makes accessible: Daniel Memmert on cognition and sports expertise (2010-2020), Yu and Liao on motor expertise (2010-2020), and Williams and Hodges on ecological deliberate practice (2005-2020). RNP integrates these sources as they are published, in keeping with its commitment to stay in continuous dialogue with current research.

Now, in practice

Do you coach or train athletes? Read Gray's How We Learn to Move to bring his ecological synthesis into your sessions and adjust your coaching to your athletes' four functional levels.

Do you work in rehabilitation? Read Internal versus External Focus of Attention (Wulf) to adjust attentional focus during return-to-activity work after injury and support transfer to the target functional context.

Do you support learning and emotional development? Read Nonlinear pedagogy (Chow Davids 2007) to apply nonlinear pedagogy with children who struggle with motor learning or are losing motor skills.

Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements health care and does not replace it. Rob Gray's work is a contemporary legacy connected to NIT in the field of non-medical ecological motor learning.

€0Your free RNP PathsStart