- RNP
- Sensorimotor Loop and Motor Control
- Loop and decision
- Motor decision: not a command, but the pre-reflexive act you have 280 milliseconds to read
Sensorimotor Loop and Motor ControlSeries 3/4
SeriesLoop and decision3 of 4
Motor decision: not a command, but the pre-reflexive act you have 280 milliseconds to read
Motor decision is the act by which the nervous system selects, in the 100 to 300 milliseconds before a movement, the postural and motor strategy best suited to the available sensory context.
In brief. Motor decision is the act by which the nervous system selects, in the 100 to 300 milliseconds before a movement, the postural and motor strategy best suited to the available sensory context. It is made upstream of the muscle. It draws on the integration of the three sensory systems (visual, vestibular, somatosensory), with an emotional dimension built into functional neurology through emotional priority and Damasio's somatic markers. It also draws on primitive reflexes (integrated or residual), learned motor patterns and the contextual appraisal of threat. In RNP, reading the motor decision before it produces the movement is the first clinical act. Reprogramming the decision, rather than correcting the movement, is the second.
Why motor decision is central to Neuro-Postural Reprogramming
A sprint ground contact lasts a hundred milliseconds. Proprioceptive feedback takes between one hundred and two hundred milliseconds to reach the brain (Shadmehr 2010). The math is simple: when your athlete's foot hits the ground, their brain does not yet know it has landed. Movement is not controlled in real time. It is predicted, in a window between one hundred and three hundred milliseconds before the movement. LabO RNP calls this pre-reflexive prediction the motor decision.
The readiness potential that Libet measured as early as 1983 confirms this at another level. It precedes the awareness of having chosen by several hundred milliseconds. The nervous system decides. Consciousness takes note.
Now picture a strength and conditioning coach alone in front of video footage of an athlete who had plateaued with no identifiable biomechanical cause. He pauses the image 280 milliseconds before take-off. He steps through frame by frame. A quarter-degree pelvic tilt appears exactly where the untrained eye sees nothing unusual. The motor decision is written there, in the window nobody ever taught him to watch. That moment, and that moment alone, is where Neuro-Postural Reprogramming does its work.
As long as you correct the movement, you are correcting the output. As long as you have not touched the decision, you shift the compromise without resolving it. Eighty percent of the outcome of an intervention depends on reading the decision, not on the precision of the movement that results from it. This is the operational principle of RNP.
How to read the motor decision in the field
Reading the motor decision does not mean seeing the movement. It means seeing what happens just before it.
In practice, you watch the 200 to 300 ms window that precedes the movement. You look for micro pelvic tilts, scapular pre-positioning, eye orientation anticipating the target, and paraspinal tone shifting a quarter of a second before contact. The motor decision is already written there. A trained eye can read it, and frame-by-frame video shows it even more precisely. You are training yourself to see what was there all along.
You can read it live, from the side, by tracking gaze orientation and tone pre-tension. You can read it on frame-by-frame video for elite athletes or complex cases, exactly as Romain did with his jumper. You can also infer it through postural tests that force the system to reveal itself: a single-leg stance with eyes closed, a jaw rotation, or a tilt induced by a foot wedge. Then you see which strategy the system chooses to compensate.
For a physical therapist facing recurrent low back pain, the motor decision to read is almost always a protective strategy the system adopted long ago and that no longer serves any purpose. The contextual threat is gone. The decision still holds. The movement, corrected six times, keeps coming back because the decision itself was never touched.
For a strength and conditioning coach facing an athlete who plateaus with no identifiable biomechanical cause, the motor decision to read is a frozen strategy. It pre-organizes every ground contact, every tilt and every weight transfer into a geometry that caps the result. This is the pivotal coaching case: "From a biomechanical standpoint, nothing was happening."
For a psychomotor therapist facing a child who cannot read, the motor decision to read is disrupted by residual primitive reflexes (palmar, ATNR, STNR). These reflexes permeate primary motor patterns and prevent eye-hand integration. Integrating the reflex frees the decision upstream of the reading movement.
One reading grid. Three professions.
The RNP training space, free for life
Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.
What you hear people say
You hear that the brain controls movement in real time. The numbers make this idea untenable. Conduction delays for proprioceptive feedback are one hundred to two hundred milliseconds (Shadmehr 2010), and a sprint ground contact lasts one hundred milliseconds. The feedback does not arrive in time. The motor decision is not a command. It is a proprioceptive prediction that spinal reflexes fulfil by minimizing prediction error (Friston 2011). This distinction is a principle of RNP.
You hear that the motor decision is too subtle, too fast, invisible. It is under-observed, which is not the same thing. A trained eye reads the decision in the 200–300 ms window. This is a professional skill that can be learned, not a gift.
Above all, you hear that motor decision is a matter of motivation or focus. RNP answers with a simple formula: Not motivation. Not commitment. Not a lack of work. A lack of reading. The decision is pre-reflexive. It is made before any voluntary effort. Working on the motivation of an athlete whose motor decision is frozen is like turning up the volume on a radio tuned to the wrong station.
Finally, you hear that speaking of the nervous system's "decision" is anthropomorphism. The term is an operational metaphor for movement professionals, not a computational thesis about conscious cognition. What matters in the field is that there is a moment, measurable and readable, when the system picks one strategy among N possible ones. That is the moment you learn to read, without having to settle the Friston-Gibson-Dennett debate in philosophy of mind.
Further reading
Core concepts: Sensorimotor loop
Neurological mechanisms: Efference copy (von Holst-Mittelstaedt 1950) · Libet: Readiness potential · RNP Neuroanatomical Pathways: Overview
Primitive reflexes · Primitive reflexes that disrupt the decision: Primitive reflex (definition) · Asymmetric Tonic Neck Reflex · Palmar Grasp Reflex · Dual sensorimotor effect
Posturology · The three sensory systems that inform the decision: The three sensory systems: visual, vestibular, somatosensory · Visual System · Vestibular system · Somatosensory system · Sensory reweighting · Somatic markers (Damasio)
NIT · Reprogramming the decision: NIT: Neuro Interval Training · Test, targeted stimulation, retest
Going further (scientific references)
Motor decision has been studied continuously for a century, in fields that did not talk to each other.
In 1906, Sherrington set out the reflex arc and the concept of a sensorimotor circuit in which movement is an output, not a cause. In 1967, Bernstein formalized the degrees of freedom problem in Dexterity and Its Development. With every movement, the nervous system must choose one organization among N possible ones. This is the direct conceptual ancestor of motor decision.
In 1983, Libet measured the readiness potential, which precedes the awareness of having chosen by 350 to 500 milliseconds. This showed experimentally that the decision is pre-reflexive. In 2010, Shadmehr established the conduction delays of proprioceptive feedback (100–200 ms), which make continuous online control impossible for ballistic movements. In 2011, Friston formalized active inference in Neuron: the motor decision is a proprioceptive prediction that minimizes error. Between 1994 and 2018, Damasio brought emotional and somatic appraisal back into bodily decision-making. His work underpins the integration of emotional priority into functional neurology.
LabO RNP does not add a new scientific thesis to this lineage. It adds the operational grid that makes motor decision readable by a non-medical professional, and reprogrammable as early as Monday morning.
The motor decision is not visible in the movement. It is visible in the window you have learned to watch.
Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements medical care; it does not replace it.