- RNP
- Functional Neurology and Neuroanatomy
- Functional neurology: its authors, its critics, its use
- Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde critique of Carrick's functional neurology
Functional Neurology and NeuroanatomySeries 5/6
SeriesFunctional neurology: its authors, its critics, its use5 of 6
Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde critique of Carrick's functional neurology
The Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde critique of Carrick's functional neurology anchors scientific rigor in how RNP reads the landscape of human movement.
In short. In RNP, the Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde critique of Carrick's functional neurology refers to the critical lineage tied to scientific rigor. In 2020, Marc Demortier and Charlotte Leboeuf-Yde published a rigorous methodological critique of the Functional Neurology developed by Carrick and colleagues, documenting its methodological weaknesses and the lack of solid scientific support. RNP incorporates this critique to anchor its own scientific rigor and to reject schools that are clinically appealing but scientifically fragile.
Why does Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde 2020 matter to the human movement professional?
Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde 2020 is one of the central critical lineages behind scientific rigor in RNP. Its practical value comes from the depth of its rigorous methodological critique, applied to a clinically appealing school (Carrick's Functional Neurology). RNP treats Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde 2020 as a critical lineage that anchors scientific rigor in how we read the landscape of human movement.
The critique rests on several key principles. A rigorous methodological critique (not an ad hominem attack). Documentation of methodological weaknesses (no solid scientific support, methodological bias, lack of independent replication). Application to a clinically appealing school (Carrick's Functional Neurology). A place within the contemporary tradition of open science and critical appraisal.
RNP integrates Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde 2020 at several points.
The Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde critique of Carrick's functional neurology is the critical lineage that anchors scientific rigor in how we read the landscape of human movement.
How Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde applies in practice
Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde applies to the critical appraisal of clinically appealing schools, to distinguishing RNP from fragile schools, and to rigorous collegial communication.
Critical appraisal of clinically appealing schools. You appraise clinically appealing schools critically (Carrick's Functional Neurology, but also other schools in the human movement landscape), drawing on the Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde lineage and on scientific rigor. You refuse ad hominem readings.
Distinguishing RNP. You explicitly distinguish RNP from fragile schools. RNP's medulla–cerebellum Neuro Interval Training is functional, not a form of anatomical cerebellar work. You name this distinction in your public and collegial communication.
Rigorous collegial communication. You communicate with peers with scientific rigor. You reject the vague syncretism that blends the RNP framework with fragile schools.
The RNP training space, free for life
Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.
What you hear people say
The first misconception comes from academic controversy. You hear "Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde is just a turf war between schools." The critique is rigorous and methodological, not polemical. Scientific rigor demands methodological critique of every school, including the appealing ones.
The second misconception comes from vague syncretism. You hear "RNP and Functional Neurology are compatible, let's use both." Scientific rigor demands that RNP be explicitly distinguished from fragile schools.
The third misconception comes from the idea of a personal attack. You hear "Demortier and Leboeuf-Yde are going after Carrick personally." The critique is strictly methodological. Scientific rigor means criticizing methods, not people.
The Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde critique of Carrick's functional neurology is the rigorous methodological lineage that anchors scientific rigor.
Read more
Distinguishing RNP: Oculomotor stimulation
Scientific lineages: Bastiere 2024 (contemporary validation of the residual Asymmetric Tonic Neck Reflex in elite athletes) · Goddard Blythe: INPP and primitive reflex integration · Ayres Sensory Integration
Going further
The Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde critique of Carrick's functional neurology belongs to the contemporary tradition of open science and critical appraisal of clinical schools.
In 2020, Marc Demortier and Charlotte Leboeuf-Yde (a chiropractic researcher known for her rigorous methodological work) published a rigorous methodological critique of the Functional Neurology developed by Carrick and colleagues, documenting its methodological weaknesses and the lack of solid scientific support.
The Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde lineage belongs to the contemporary open-science tradition, which calls for critical appraisal of clinically appealing schools in order to anchor scientific rigor.
Now, in practice
Distinguish RNP from Carrick's cerebellar stimulation.
Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements medical follow-up; it does not replace it. The Demortier & Leboeuf-Yde critique of Carrick's functional neurology refers to a critical lineage tied to scientific rigor in RNP.