- RNP
- Functional Neurology and Neuroanatomy
- Carrick: applied functional neurology (with a critical reading)
Functional Neurology and NeuroanatomySeries 1/6
SeriesFunctional neurology: its authors, its critics, its use1 of 6
Carrick: applied functional neurology (with a critical reading)
Applied functional neurology, read alongside the Demortier-Leboeuf 2020 methodological critique.
In short. Frederick Carrick is the American chiropractic neurologist who founded applied functional neurology, a field developed since 1979 that uses targeted sensory stimulation to modulate hemispheric organization and neurofunctional asymmetries. He is not a reference to be accepted without reservation. RNP integrates Carrick's contribution to functional neurology with strengthened methodological rigor, informed by the Demortier-Leboeuf (2020) critique, which documented the methodological weaknesses of the school's efficacy studies.
Why is Carrick's contribution central for the human movement professional, and why is the critical reading built into it?
Frederick Carrick and the school of applied functional neurology are among the historical sources of the neurofunctional reading that underpins functional neurology. RNP explicitly acknowledges Carrick's conceptual contribution to the clinical teaching of targeted sensory stimulation as a way to modulate hemispheric organization and integration asymmetries. This conceptual contribution is central to how functional neurology is structured.
However, RNP explicitly refuses a naive adoption of Carrick's legacy. Scientific scrutiny of the Carrick school intensified during the 2010s. The methodological review by Demortier and Leboeuf (2020, Chiropractic and Manual Therapies) documented in depth the methodological weaknesses of several efficacy studies from the Carrick school: insufficient sample sizes, absent or weak controls, selection bias, confirmation bias, and hasty interpretation of fluctuating measurements. The review calls for strengthened methodological rigor when reading the school's clinical claims and in any practice that invokes it. See also: Demortier-Leboeuf 2020: methodological critique of Carrick.
RNP builds this critique structurally into its approach to functional neurology. This critical integration sets it apart from a dogmatic adoption of the Carrick school and gives it stronger epistemic defensibility.
Carrick's contribution and the school of applied functional neurology are neither a rejected reference nor one accepted without nuance. RNP integrates the fruitful hypotheses of functional neurology with a structural methodological critique (Demortier-Leboeuf 2020), the rigor of the documented test-stimulation-retest (T-S-R) cycle, and the five epistemic anti-fallacies.
How Carrick's contribution, read critically, applies in practice
Read with a critical eye, Carrick's contribution applies to reading integration asymmetries, to rigorously calibrating functional neurology stimulation, and to systematic test-stimulation-retest documentation.
Reading integration asymmetries. You read the hemibody sensory integration asymmetries inherited from applied neurofunctional reading, but you read them with the rigor of the five anti-fallacies. The first anti-fallacy, correlation versus causation: an observed asymmetry does not necessarily have a direct functional causal link with the clinical complaint. The second anti-fallacy, the clinical anecdote: an asymmetry observed in a handful of clients does not make it a generic diagnostic marker. The third anti-fallacy, all-or-nothing: an observed asymmetry is not binary but is qualified by its magnitude, durability and generalization.
Rigorous calibration of functional neurology stimulation. You calibrate functional neurology stimulation according to the targeted sensory substrate (vestibular, oculomotor, deep somatosensory, preparatory cortex) inherited from Carrick's reading, but you also calibrate the dose, specificity and timing of application with rigor.
Systematic test-stimulation-retest documentation. Every functional neurology stimulation inspired by Carrick's reading sits within the documented, multi-timepoint T-S-R cycle (immediate retest, then retests at three days, one week and three weeks). This systematic documentation responds directly to the Demortier-Leboeuf methodological critique by progressively building, across a cohort, clinical data that goes beyond anecdote.
The RNP training space, free for life
Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.
What you hear
The first confusion comes from dogmatic, uncritical adoption. You hear "functional neurology has proven everything, we can apply it directly." RNP explicitly rejects this dogmatic adoption. See also: Demortier-Leboeuf 2020: methodological critique of Carrick. The RNP practitioner integrates the fruitful conceptual hypotheses of functional neurology while applying the rigor of the five anti-fallacies and the documented T-S-R cycle.
The second confusion comes from rejecting Carrick's legacy wholesale. You hear "functional neurology is methodologically weak, so we throw everything out." RNP also rejects this binary, wholesale dismissal. Several fruitful conceptual hypotheses (targeted sensory stimulation, functional hemispheric modulation, integration asymmetries) remain operational and clinically informative when handled with appropriate methodological rigor.
The third confusion comes from scope overreach through neurological marketing promises. You hear "functional neurology fixes neurological disorders through stimulation." RNP integrates some of Carrick's hypotheses into functional neurology within a functional, non-medical sensorimotor framework, without encroaching on the medical scope of clinical neurology.
Carrick's contribution is a historical lineage integrated into functional neurology, with a central methodological critique and the rigor of the documented T-S-R cycle.
Further reading
Historical and critical lineage: Demortier-Leboeuf 2020: methodological critique of Carrick · Functional neurology school · Melillo Brain Balance
Functional neurology, critical integration: RNP Neuroanatomical Pathways: Overview
Historical lineage: Sherrington: the reflex arc and integrative neurophysiology (1906) · Postural muscle tone and body posture , Magnus 1924 · Goddard Blythe: INPP and primitive reflex integration · Bernstein: Coordination and the degrees of freedom problem (1967)
Going further
The work of Carrick and the school of applied functional neurology form a lineage that is both clinically influential and scientifically debated on methodological grounds.
Frederick Carrick (United States, Carrick Institute for Graduate Studies, since 1979) founded the clinical teaching of applied functional neurology from a chiropractic background. The Carrick school has trained several thousand practitioners (mainly North American and international chiropractors, but also physicians, physical therapists, osteopaths and behavioral optometrists) in dozens of countries. Carrick has published numerous clinical articles and contributed to continuing education in functional neurology within chiropractic colleges.
Robert Melillo (United States, Brain Balance Achievement Centers) popularized the functional reading of the hemispheres in the field of child development and published several books for a general audience (Disconnected Kids 2009, Reconnected Kids 2011). This lineage helped spread the neurofunctional reading into the pediatric field.
Methodological criticism of the Carrick school intensified during the 2010s. The methodological review by Demortier P. and Leboeuf-Yde C. (2020, Chiropractic and Manual Therapies, "Chiropractic functional neurology: a critical analysis of the evidence") documented in depth the methodological weaknesses of several efficacy studies published by the Carrick school. This critical review calls for strengthened methodological rigor and is the reference critique that RNP integrates into its handling of functional neurology. See also: Demortier-Leboeuf 2020: methodological critique of Carrick.
Broader critical work on chiropractic practices (Edzard Ernst, Trick or Treatment, 2008; Tim Caulfield on pseudoscientific practices) has documented the classic interpretive traps of clinical practices that borrow neuroscientific vocabulary without matching methodological rigor. RNP incorporates this critical tradition through the five epistemic anti-fallacies.
RNP maintains a respectful but critically vigilant relationship with Carrick's legacy. Its functional neurology retains the fruitful conceptual hypotheses (targeted sensory stimulation, hemispheric modulation, integration asymmetries) while requiring the rigor of the documented T-S-R cycle and strict application of the five anti-fallacies. This critical articulation is one of RNP's original contributions to the contemporary field of non-medical applied functional neurology.
Now, in practice
Working in rehab? Read Demortier-Leboeuf 2020: methodological critique of Carrick to bring this methodological critique into your functional neurology reading and build a rigorous, epistemically defensible practice.
Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements medical care; it does not replace it. Carrick's contribution refers to a historical lineage integrated critically into functional neurology within the functional, non-medical sensorimotor field.