- RNP
- Functional Neurology and Neuroanatomy
- Functional neurology: its authors, its critics, its use
- Demortier-Leboeuf 2020: methodological critique of Carrick
Functional Neurology and NeuroanatomySeries 4/6
SeriesFunctional neurology: its authors, its critics, its use4 of 6
Demortier-Leboeuf 2020: methodological critique of Carrick
The 2020 methodological review that separates the fruitful hypotheses of the Carrick school from the weaknesses of its efficacy studies.
In brief. Demortier-Leboeuf 2020 refers to the methodological review published by P. Demortier and C. Leboeuf-Yde in Chiropractic and Manual Therapies (2020), which thoroughly documented the methodological weaknesses of several efficacy studies from Frederick Carrick's school of applied functional neurology. This critical review is the central foundation of RNP's critical reading of the Carrick school: RNP retains the fruitful hypotheses of functional neurology while demanding the rigor of a documented Test–Stimulation–Retest (T-S-R) cycle and the five anti-fallacies.
Why is Demortier-Leboeuf 2020 central to the RNP discipline?
Demortier-Leboeuf 2020 is the central foundation of RNP's critical reading of the Carrick school. Without this critical review, integrating Carrick's contribution to functional neurology could look like an uncritical adoption of a methodologically contested school. With the review fully integrated, RNP shows that it can work with the fruitful hypotheses without hiding the methodological weaknesses.
The review brings together several critical contributions. It documents methodological weaknesses (insufficient sample sizes, absent or weak controls, selection bias, confirmation bias, hasty interpretation of fluctuating measurements). It calls for stronger methodological rigor when reading clinical claims. And it distinguishes fruitful conceptual hypotheses from the efficacy evidence actually available. See also: Carrick: applied functional neurology (with a critical reading).
RNP integrates Demortier-Leboeuf at several points.
Demortier-Leboeuf 2020 is not an academic dismissal of the Carrick school. It is the reference methodological review underpinning RNP's critical reading of Carrick's contribution.
How the Demortier-Leboeuf foundation applies in practice
It applies in the critical reading of Carrick claims, in well-articulated collegial communication, and in applying the five anti-fallacies.
Critical reading of claims. You read the clinical claims of the Carrick school with the methodological rigor documented by Demortier-Leboeuf. You keep the fruitful hypotheses while avoiding premature generalization.
Well-articulated collegial communication. You explain to your chiropractor, physical therapist and physician colleagues, respectfully, how the critical integration of Carrick's contribution fits with the methodological rigor required. This clarity protects the professional stance of the RNP practitioner when questions about scientific validity come up.
Applying the five anti-fallacies. You apply the anti-fallacies when reading your own T-S-R results inspired by Carrick's hypotheses. The first anti-fallacy concerns premature causal claims, the second concerns anecdote.
The RNP training space, free for life
Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.
What you hear
The first misconception is wholesale rejection. Demortier-Leboeuf 2020 does not reject Carrick wholesale. It criticizes methodological weaknesses while acknowledging that fruitful hypotheses may exist.
The second is concealment. You hear: “better not to mention this critique.”
The third is a single-paradigm reading. RNP integrates the critique while retaining the fruitful hypotheses.
Demortier-Leboeuf 2020 is neither a wholesale rejection, nor a critique to be hidden, nor a single-paradigm argument.
Read also
Historical lineage: Carrick: applied functional neurology (with a critical reading) · Sherrington: the reflex arc and integrative neurophysiology (1906) · Postural muscle tone and body posture , Magnus 1924
Going further
P. Demortier and C. Leboeuf-Yde published their critical review, Chiropractic functional neurology: a critical analysis of the evidence, in Chiropractic and Manual Therapies in 2020. The review analyzes the efficacy studies published by the Carrick school and documents recurring methodological weaknesses.
Charlotte Leboeuf-Yde is one of the most internationally recognized chiropractic researchers for her work applying evidence-based medicine to the chiropractic field. Her involvement gives the critical review strong epistemic credibility.
The review belongs to the contemporary tradition of methodological auditing of clinical schools (Edzard Ernst's Trick or Treatment, 2008; Cochrane reviews of alternative practices), which separates fruitful hypotheses from methodological weaknesses in efficacy evidence.
RNP integrates this critical tradition into its treatment of functional neurology and stands as one of the original contributions to the contemporary field of applied functional neurology.
Now, in practice
Working in rehabilitation? Read Carrick: applied functional neurology (with a critical reading) to bring methodological critical reading into your practice.
Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements healthcare follow-up; it does not replace it. Demortier-Leboeuf 2020 refers to a methodological foundation for RNP's critical reading of Carrick's contribution.