- RNP
- Sensorimotor Loop and Motor Control
- Before the movement: prediction and motor decision
- Proprioceptive conduction delays
Sensorimotor Loop and Motor ControlSeries 15/15
SeriesBefore the movement: prediction and motor decision15 of 15
Proprioceptive conduction delays
The researcher who put numbers on why the brain cannot correct a fast movement in real time, and must anticipate it instead.
In brief. Reza Shadmehr is a motor control researcher. His work, notably with Smith and Krakauer (2010), showed that sensory feedback is both noisy and delayed, by roughly one hundred to two hundred milliseconds. This delay makes it impossible to steer a fast movement using feedback alone, and forces the brain to anticipate the consequences of its actions through internal models. In RNP, this finding underpins the predictive reading of the motor decision.
Why a fast movement cannot be steered in real time
The idea is as simple as it is radical. Proprioceptive information does not come back instantly: it takes on the order of one hundred to two hundred milliseconds to travel up and be processed. For a ballistic movement, such as a throw, a strike or a quick foot plant, that is far too slow. By the time the error signal arrives, the movement is already over. The brain therefore cannot simply react to feedback, or it would always be one step behind.
Its solution is to predict. Based on the command it sends out, it estimates in advance the expected sensory consequences, using internal models supported in particular by the cerebellum. Motor learning then consists of correcting the gap between this prediction and what actually happened: the sensory prediction error.
The RNP reading
This finding gives a scientific foundation to the predictive motor decision. We do not read movement as a series of real-time corrections, but as an anticipation that is recalibrated against the gap. This logic connects with active inference and with the tension between ecological dynamics and predictive coding. For the human movement professional, it highlights that the quality of anticipation matters just as much as the quality of execution.
→ Related terms: Motor decision: not a command, the pre-reflexive act you have 280 milliseconds to read · Sensorimotor loop · Active inference (Friston) · Ecological dynamics versus predictive coding · Cerebellum
Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements healthcare follow-up and does not replace it. The work cited belongs to the neurophysiology of motor control.
The RNP training space, free for life
Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.