1. RNP
  2. Motor Learning
  3. Feedback, guidance and autonomy
  4. Feedback (KR / KP): why your best feedback is often the one you don't give

Motor LearningSeries 4/13

SeriesFeedback, guidance and autonomy4 of 13

Feedback (KR / KP): why your best feedback is often the one you don't give

KR tells the learner about the outcome, KP about the movement. Understand the distinction, the feedback paradox, and the question that shows whether you are building autonomy or dependency.

LabO RNP·8 min read·reviewed on

In brief. Feedback is any information provided after an action, internal or external, that shapes how future actions are adjusted. There are two kinds. KR (knowledge of results) tells the learner about the outcome of the action. KP (knowledge of performance) tells them about how the action was carried out.

A double-edged sword, not a gift

Watch your hands during a session. How many times do they reach out to correct an angle? How many times does your voice break the silence to adjust a foot placement? You think you're helping. You may be sabotaging.

Feedback is not neutral. It can speed up learning or wreck it, and in most professional practice, it sabotages it. Not out of bad intent. It happens because feedback is given too often, too precisely and too early. It replaces perception instead of developing it.

The first distinction to get clear is between outcome and form. KR, Knowledge of Results, gives information about the outcome of the action: the target is hit or missed, the bar clears or falls. KP, Knowledge of Performance, gives information about how the action was carried out: the elbow angle, the rhythm of the foot strike, the position of the back. These are two different objects, with two different effects on performance and on what remains once the session is over.

The crutch: the image that makes it all click

Picture the weight of a crutch under your arm. Used occasionally, it gets you back on your feet. You need temporary support, and it lets you keep moving while you recover.

Used all the time, it stops you from walking on your own. You become dependent. Your muscles don't get stronger and your balance doesn't develop. You become an expert at walking with a crutch and build no independent capacity at all. Too much feedback improves walking with the crutch, but delays autonomy.

This is exactly what happens in practice. The athlete performs beautifully when you're there and falls apart as soon as you're not, because they have learned to use your feedback as a crutch. They never developed their own calibration loop and never connected their own sensorimotor loop to the action.

The RNP training space, free for life

Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.

Welcome! Introduce yourself

SecureNo cardNo password

By continuing, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.

What feedback is not: stop overrating it

You can still hear that little voice telling you that intervening well means intervening often. Switch it off. Feedback is not always beneficial, and it is not needed on every repetition. It is not the same thing as good teaching. It doesn't prove expertise and it doesn't guarantee learning.

The common mistake, the one that still shapes most interventions, is to believe that the more you explain, the more people learn. Excessive feedback creates dependency. The good coach is not the one who gives the most feedback. It's the one who knows when to stay quiet, who doses the intervention and lets the system find its own solutions. That coach understands that every piece of feedback takes away a chance for the system to learn on its own.

Feedback is not a way to show off your expertise. It's a learning tool, and like any tool it can be used well or badly. Most of the time it's used badly: too frequent, too precise, too immediate. All three problems are fixed through feedback frequency and timing.

What this changes in practice: three scenes

Put your hand on an athlete's bar. You give precise feedback on every rep: angle, timing, posture. You correct constantly, you guide, you adjust. The performance looks clean in the session, everything seems optimal, and you sign it off. The result is collapse once the coach is gone. The athlete can only perform when you're there, telling them what to do and correcting in real time. The system has learned to listen, not to perceive. It has developed a dependency on your external feedback and never built its own internal perception. The effective intervention is to space out feedback, favor KR over KP and let the error inform. You give information about the outcome, not the form, and that pushes the athlete to develop their own perception.

Change rooms. A child is verbally corrected on every attempt. You tell them how to do it, you show them, you guide them step by step. They succeed under guidance, everything seems to work, and you sign it off. The result is success only with guidance and an inability to self-adjust. The child learns that the right answer comes from the adult, that they have to wait for your instructions and can't find it alone. You have created a cognitive dependency: they build no confidence in their own ability to explore and adjust. The effective intervention is rare feedback, open questions and independent exploration.

Last scene, in allied health and functional settings. A client receives constant postural corrections. You step in as soon as they drift, tell them how to stand, correct them non-stop. The movement looks clean under your supervision, and you sign it off. The result is rigidity, over-control and no transfer. The client only moves well while you're watching, and once alone they fall back into their usual patterns. The feedback replaces body perception instead of restoring it. They never developed their own sensitivity, their own regulation loop or their perceptual autonomy.

The professional mistake that manufactures dependency

The mistake fits in one sentence: confusing feedback with information that actually serves learning. This confusion flatters the practitioner's role and is reassuring in the short term, but it destroys independent learning.

Every piece of feedback should be justified by a clear intention. Not given by reflex. Not given to show you're there. Not given to reassure. Given because you have spotted a specific moment when a specific piece of information will help the system recalibrate. The problem is that most feedback isn't justified. It comes from habit, from professional reflex, from the need to show expertise, or from discomfort with silence.

Every unjustified piece of feedback creates dependency. Every correction takes away a chance for the system to detect the problem itself. It replaces a perception that should have emerged on its own and feeds a performance illusion that won't survive your absence.

The calibration question: test yourself now

Here is the question that settles it: if I remove feedback completely, does the system still find a solution?

No? Then you have created dependency. The system can only function with your help, and as soon as you withdraw it, it collapses. You haven't created independent learning, only guided performance. Yes? Then your feedback is well dosed. The system has developed its own calibration loop and can detect, adjust and learn without you. Your feedback supported learning without creating dependency.

This question reveals everything. It tells you whether you have built autonomy or dependency, perception or external control, and whether you have built learning or simply kept guided performance going.

The feedback paradox

Research in motor learning, synthesized in particular by Rob Gray in How We Learn to Move, shows something counterintuitive but fundamental. Frequent feedback improves immediate performance, but it degrades retention, transfer and self-regulation.

Less feedback can lead to more learning.

This is the feedback paradox. What improves the session sabotages learning, and what reassures in the short term destroys in the long term. Less feedback forces the system to develop its own perception, to detect things itself, and to build an internal calibration loop rather than relying on an external one. This shift from external to internal also shapes the relationship between internal and external feedback. It's hard to accept because it goes against every social expectation: a good coach is supposed to correct, guide and explain. But a coach who truly understands learning knows when to stay quiet and let the error inform. They also know when to space out feedback so the learner has to become autonomous.

The role of this benchmark: redefining your stance

This benchmark redefines the practitioner's stance. From now on, silence becomes a tool, feedback becomes rare and strategic, and error regains its informative role. Good feedback doesn't tell the learner what to do. It helps the system understand. It gives information about the outcome, not the form, and lets the system find the way without imposing the solution.

Feedback is not the enemy, but excessive feedback is. Most interventions suffer from too much feedback, not too little. Your role is not to be a permanent source of external information. It is to create the conditions for the system to develop its own internal source. So cut back your feedback, space it out and make it strategic. Favor KR over KP. Let the system explore, let error inform and put up with the discomfort of silence. Accept a messier session in the short term so that learning holds up in the long term.

You move from constant corrector to occasional facilitator, from the expert who tells to the expert who lets people discover. Feedback is a powerful tool, and like every powerful tool it should be used sparingly and with intention. Most of the time, the best feedback is none at all.

In one sentence: KR is about the outcome, KP is about the movement, and the only feedback that builds autonomy is the feedback you deliberately choose to give or hold back.

Field test: at your next session, pick one exercise and cut all feedback on form (KP). Give only the outcome (KR), or nothing at all. Watch whether the system finds a solution on its own. If it does, you have built perception. If it falls apart, you are seeing the dependency you had built in.

At LabO RNP, we no longer judge practitioners by what they say, but by what the system can do when they stay quiet. I want to help you build that stance into your practice.

Scope: a functional, non-medical approach. It complements healthcare follow-up; it does not replace it.

€0Your free RNP PathsStart