- RNP
- Child Motor Development and Learning
- The pyramid of learning
- The Pyramid of Learning and motor learning: from foundation to learned skill
Child Motor Development and LearningSeries 11/14
SeriesThe pyramid of learning11 of 14
The Pyramid of Learning and motor learning: from foundation to learned skill
The Pyramid of Learning and motor learning: what each level brings to a skill, what it leaves unsaid, and how to check whether the skill actually sticks.
The Pyramid of Learning and motor learning: two maps for the same skill
The Pyramid of Learning (Taylor and Trott, 1991; Williams and Shellenberger, 1996) lays out what a child or an athlete needs to have available in order to learn. Motor learning describes how a skill is acquired and verified: retention, transfer, robustness under constraint. One reads the conditions, the other the process.
Hello to you, movement professional,
You know the session that ends well. The athlete searched for a long time, you finally found the right cue, and the movement at last comes out clean. You head home pleased. A week later they come back, and everything has to be redone, as if that session had never happened.
Faced with this scene, two instincts compete. The first looks underneath the movement: it opens Williams and Shellenberger's pyramid and looks for the missing level. The second looks at the session: the movement was obtained with your voice, your eye and your cue, and nobody checked whether it held without them. Both hold part of the truth, and they answer two different questions.
What the pyramid describes, what motor learning measures
The pyramid is a still image. It shows what supports what, from the central nervous system up to academic learning, and it stops there. You will find no box in it for what remains from one week to the next, or for what carries over from the gym to the field. It makes it clear at a glance why reading also depends on balance, and it doesn't have to settle that other question.
Motor learning deals precisely with what the diagram leaves out. In our vocabulary, it is a lasting transformation in the capacity to adapt to a class of situations. It shows up in three signs: retention after a period without practice, transfer to another context, and holding up under constraint when fatigue or pressure rise.
The session itself is misleading. Nicholas Soderstrom and Robert Bjork (2015) gathered the research on the gap between performance and learning, a gap studied for decades. Performance during practice often predicts poorly what will be retained, and some conditions that lower it actually improve long-term learning. That is the whole point of the performance, retention, transfer triangle, and it explains your athlete the following week.
The two frameworks don't run on the same clock either. The pyramid thinks in years of development, motor learning in sessions and weeks. When you switch from one to the other without saying so, you explain an eight-day lapse with a tool built to tell the story of a childhood.
The RNP training space, free for life
Get access to RNP training, no strings attached.
The phases of motor learning, seen from the levels
In 1967, Paul Fitts and Michael Posner described three phases in acquiring a skill. The cognitive phase, where the person understands what they have to do and almost talks themselves through it out loud. The associative phase, where they refine it. The autonomous phase, where the movement runs on its own and leaves attention free for something else. Our glossary speaks of three functional levels, conscious control, automaticity and adaptive capacity, with one extra requirement: an automated movement can remain fragile as long as it doesn't adapt.
Set beside the pyramid, this progression tells a story. The beginner works from the top: cues, working memory, voluntary attention. As motor automatization sets in, the movement seems to move down toward levels that run without conscious thought. Nobody has measured this shift; it is our way of telling it. It still has a practical consequence: an unreliable lower level might keep the athlete under conscious control for longer, because they have to monitor what others hand off to their sensors.
The other way in comes from Nikolai Bernstein and the degrees of freedom problem: the body has far more joints and muscles than the task requires, and it has to organize that surplus. Beatrix Vereijken and her colleagues (1992) followed this learning process on a ski simulator. Beginners start by freezing some of their joints, then release them as the movement becomes organized. You have surely seen that stiff body in people discovering a new movement.
Motor planning and postural security, at level 3, are good candidates for explaining why some people release faster than others. Candidates only: Vereijken's study says nothing about these skills.
Table: what each level makes available to learning
This table crosses the two maps. Its purpose is to ask a precise question in the right place, without claiming to measure anything.
Level of the pyramid | What it makes available | The question to ask during learning |
|---|---|---|
1. Central nervous system | A state of arousal that allows searching | Is the athlete available to explore today, or only to execute? |
2. Sensory systems | Information about the body and about space | Do they feel their own error, or wait for you to tell them? |
3. Sensorimotor development | The body map and the organization of a new movement | Can they organize a variation without seeing it demonstrated? |
4. Perceptual-motor development | The link between the eyes, the hands and posture | Do they read what the situation offers, or apply a fixed plan? |
5. Cognition and intellect | Understanding the task and its rules | Does the movement still hold when you take away the cue? |
LabO RNP reading grid, not a validated assessment tool. The perceptual-motor level is covered in detail in its own article.
The bridge with Newell: reading the levels as constraints
In 1986, Karl Newell proposed a simple idea: a movement emerges from the meeting of three families of constraints, those of the organism, the environment and the task. Nothing in this framework mentions a pyramid. Yet it offers a very convenient place for its levels: you can read them as organismic constraints, just like height, strength or fatigue.
James Gibson (1979) called affordance what an environment offers to the one who acts, and that offer depends on the one who acts. A low wall to climb over does not offer the same thing to a child who is sure of their footing and to a child unsettled by the drop. The wall hasn't moved. The child and the wall form a different pair.
In this reading, a fragile level becomes a starting point for tuning the task, so that it stays within reach and there is still something to search for. Nothing requires you to consolidate it before earning the right to practice. That is the meaning of constraint beats instruction, and of the constraints-led approach. This connection is ours: Newell never wrote that Taylor and Trott's pyramid fit into his model.
The movement also builds the levels beneath it
The diagram invites a misreading: it gives the impression that you finish one level before moving up to the next. Walking tells a different story. Karen Adolph and her colleagues (2012) observed infants aged 12 to 19 months in free play. They took an average of 2,368 steps and had 17 falls per hour, in short bouts, along variable paths.
Nobody waits for balance to be in place before letting them walk. Balance is built by walking, falling and setting off again on ground that keeps changing. Esther Thelen and Linda Smith (1994) built an entire account of development on this idea: skills emerge from activity itself, without a pre-set assembly plan.
The pyramid's arrow therefore points both ways. The lower levels support learning, and every session feeds them in return. The debate over where to intervene first has its own article, on bottom-up and top-down approaches, with what the meta-analyses say about it.
What we know, what we assume
Solid: the gap between performance and learning, documented for a long time and summarized by Soderstrom and Bjork. Observed, but on specific tasks: the freezing and then release of degrees of freedom. Observed in natural conditions: the volume and variability of spontaneous walking practice.
Sleep deserves a slower look, because it gets cited quickly whenever level 1 comes up. Steven Pan and Timothy Rickard (2015) reanalyzed 34 papers on motor sequence learning. Once certain calculation and protocol biases were accounted for, they found no evidence that sleep enhances this learning, and their conclusion about its stabilizing role remains open. This result concerns the gain after a night's sleep, for this type of task. A bad night can still change how available someone is that day. Our article on sleep and the previous day's movement argues for sleep as a processing stage for the movement: a position to be held with this caution in mind.
That leaves our own reading. The link between levels and phases, the levels seen as constraints, the idea that a fragile foundation delays automaticity: to our knowledge, no study has tested these connections. They are field hypotheses, useful as long as they lead to better questions.
In practice: reading a movement lost from one week to the next
Go back to your athlete from the beginning, and change the order of your questions. Before opening the pyramid, look at how the movement was obtained. How much of your voice, your reference points and your demonstration was still in it when you signed it off? If the answer makes you uncomfortable, you may already have your explanation, and there is no level to look for.
Then check what was really lost. Have them repeat the movement after a delay, without help, in the same situation, then in a different one. If it holds in the first and breaks down in the second, you are talking about transfer. If it breaks down in both, you are talking about retention, and your session most likely produced guided performance.
The pyramid takes over again when the movement refuses to organize itself, even with help, even when you change the task, and the same signal keeps returning from one activity to the next. Then the table gives you a level to suspect, and the test-stimulation-retest cycle tells you whether you were right. In Neuro-Postural Reprogramming, that last step belongs to another lens, functional neurology, which we deliberately keep separate from the ecological dynamics framework of this article.
For athletes, this is what the article on the pyramid and sports training explores, and all five tiers remain within reach in the complete guide to the pyramid. One question remains open for us: after how many sessions does a movement that won't come back stop being a practice problem and become a tier problem? We don't have a number to give you, and we'd be wary of anyone who claims to.
The pyramid tells you what might be missing. Only the movement found again a week later tells you what was learned.
The free course "How we learn to move" covers these foundations on video.
👉 I want to understand how we learn to move.
Frequently asked questions about the pyramid of learning and motor learning
What is the link between the pyramid of learning and motor learning?
The pyramid of learning describes what a person needs to have available in order to learn: arousal state, senses, motor organization, perception, cognition. Motor learning describes how a movement is acquired, retained and transferred through practice. The first framework reads the conditions, the second the process. They complement each other, and to our knowledge no study has linked them directly.
What are the stages of motor learning?
Fitts and Posner's classic model (1967) identifies three: the cognitive stage, where the person understands the task; the associative stage, where they refine the movement; and the autonomous stage, where the movement runs on its own and frees up attention. LabO RNP adds one requirement: learning is confirmed by retention, transfer and holding up under constraint.
Do you need to consolidate a tier of the pyramid before working on a movement?
Nothing demonstrates this. Walking is built precisely by walking: Adolph and colleagues (2012) counted an average of 2,368 steps and 17 falls per hour in children aged 12 to 19 months. The movement and its foundations develop together, and a fragile tier is better used to adjust the difficulty of the task.
How do you know whether a movement has really been learned?
You check it at a distance from the session and without assistance. If the movement comes back after a period without practice, there is retention. If it adapts to a different situation, there is transfer. If it holds when fatigue or pressure rises, it is robust. A strong end to a session remains an unreliable indicator, as Soderstrom and Bjork (2015) point out.
What are Newell's constraints?
Karl Newell (1986) explains that a movement emerges from the interaction of three families of constraints: organism, environment and task. Changing them changes the solutions the person finds. Reading the tiers of the pyramid as organism constraints is a proposal from LabO RNP, not something found in Newell's work.
Does sleep improve motor learning?
The evidence is less clear-cut than often claimed. Pan and Rickard's meta-analysis (2015) on motor sequence learning finds no evidence of sleep-based enhancement once several biases are accounted for, and leaves the question of stabilization open. LabO RNP considers sleep a processing stage for the movement: a position to be held with that caution in mind.
What should you do if a child seems stuck at a tier of the pyramid?
Refer the family to a physician, occupational therapist or psychomotor therapist, who have the appropriate assessment tools. The pyramid is not one of them: it helps frame a question. RNP is not a medical procedure: it complements healthcare follow-up, it does not replace it.
Sources
Taylor K., Trott M. (1991). Pyramid of Learning, diagram reproduced in Williams M.S., Shellenberger S. (1996). How Does Your Engine Run? Albuquerque: TherapyWorks.
Fitts P.M., Posner M.I. (1967). Human Performance. Belmont: Brooks/Cole.
Bernstein N.A. (1967). The Co-ordination and Regulation of Movements. Oxford: Pergamon Press.
Vereijken B., van Emmerik R.E.A., Whiting H.T.A., Newell K.M. (1992). Free(z)ing degrees of freedom in skill acquisition. Journal of Motor Behavior, 24(1), 133-142.
Newell K.M. (1986). Constraints on the development of coordination. In Wade M.G., Whiting H.T.A. (eds.), Motor Development in Children: Aspects of Coordination and Control. Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhoff, 341-360.
Gibson J.J. (1979). The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Thelen E., Smith L.B. (1994). A Dynamic Systems Approach to the Development of Cognition and Action. Cambridge: MIT Press.
Adolph K.E., Cole W.G., Komati M., Garciaguirre J.S., Badaly D., Lingeman J.M., Chan G.L.Y., Sotsky R.B. (2012). How do you learn to walk? Thousands of steps and dozens of falls per day. Psychological Science, 23(11), 1387-1394.
Soderstrom N.C., Bjork R.A. (2015). Learning versus performance: an integrative review. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 10(2), 176-199.
Pan S.C., Rickard T.C. (2015). Sleep and motor learning: is there room for consolidation? Psychological Bulletin, 141(4), 812-834.
By the LabO RNP team